It’s only the middle of June but I’ve been thinking about football since March (I usually go comatose for a month after the Super Bowl in order to recoup from the season). If you haven’t seen them yet, make sure you check out my pre-season picks or buy a copy of the NFL 2008 PREDICTOPOTAMUS.
We’re about a month away from training camps and a month-and-a-half away from the first pre-season games. What better time than the present to talk about those teams that year in and year out get picked by analysts to succeed, then come up short.
#10 - Houston Texans
Houston hasn’t finished better than .500 in their six years of existence. Unfortunately for them, the previous three expansion teams (Cleveland, Carolina and Jacksonville) all made it to the playoffs relatively quickly and expectations have been a bit higher than they should have been. The Texans’ draft picks have been good but not great and their off-season acquisitions haven’t panned out like many analysts thought they would. I think that most people generally expect Houston to finish in the .500 range every year but they’ve only come close twice, which is why they’re my #10 Trendiest Pre-Season Pick.
#9 - Miami Dolphins
I think we all remember 2004 when the trendy picks were Carolina and Miami, and then both teams tanked and missed the playoffs. That, coupled with the 1-15 record the ‘Fins posted in 2007, will scare a lot of analysts away from Miami in 2008. The Dolphins, however, are seemingly always on somebody’s list to make the playoffs. They had 15 consecutive seasons of .500 or better from 1989 to 2003, so they have winning history behind them, and they won 9 games in 2005 so it wouldn’t really shock anybody to see Miami catch some momentum.
#8 - New York Jets
Since 2002 the Jets have been alternating playoff seasons, and that unpredictability makes a lot of analysts afraid to pick against them. Last year they went 4-12, so will they make another jump up to 10-6 like they did from 2005 to 2006? Will they tank it? Who knows. That’s why they’re #8 on my list of the Trendiest Pre-Season Picks.
#7 - New Orleans Saints
In 2005 the Saints suffered through the aftereffects of Hurrican Katrina and won only three games. Expectations for 2006 were pretty low and the leap to 10-6 and NFC Runner-Up caught the nation off guard. In 2007 the Saints were a VERY trendy pick to go to the Super Bowl but they came up short and finished 7-9. Any time you have a team with a good offense and poor defense the analysts will be all over the place with their predictions, but the emotional factor (everybody loves New Orleans now) makes the Saints a trendy pick again in 2008.
#6 - Denver Broncos
Like Miami, the Broncos have a winning tradition behind them that makes them seem like a Super Bowl contender every pre-season. They do make the playoffs on a pretty consistent basis but where are the championships? Where are the rings? This is a team that wins regular season games and then flops in the playoffs (see violent losses in 2003 and 2004 to Indianapolis). Undoubtedly they’ll be expected to contend in the weak AFC West, but don’t get your hopes up for greatness.
#5 - Cincinnati Bengals
The Carson Palmer Era was supposed to include annual playoff appearances and some championships. In 2005 they almost made it but an injury to the aforementioned quarterback in the playoffs sent them home early. In 2006 analysts (including myself) expected Palmer to lead his team back to the post-season but they finished with eight wins. In 2007 analysts (including myself) expected improvement but were again met with a sub-par season and seven wins. Cincinnati has the potential every year to be a contender, but their problems both on and off the field drag them down to mediocrity. The Bengals are like your grannie’s dentures…they sure do look real but they keep falling out…and that’s why they’re my #5 Trendiest Pre-Season Pick.
#4 - Detroit Lions
What? Really? Detroit? Every year since 2002 has been “the year” for these poor suckers. Take it from me…I used to be a Lions fan until this past year. There is always at least one analyst who jumps on the Detroit bandwagon and in 2007 the Lions almost pulled off the impossible (a winning season under Matt Millen). Unfortunately the 6-2 start was followed by a 1-7 slide and things returned to normal. Undoubtedly Detroit will be picked by many to win eight games in 2008, making them a very Trend Pre-Season Pick.
#3 - Carolina Panthers
I mentioned it earlier when speaking about Miami, but I’ll say it again - everyone remembers 2004. Carolina was supposed to be really good, coming off of a very impressive Super Bowl loss to New England. They fell victim to the Super Bowl Loser’s Curse and missed the playoffs that next year but they didn’t fall far enough to drop off of the radar completely. Carolina has only ever had one really bad year and they have had three 7-9 seasons in the past six years, making them a consistent playoff pick in the NFC.
#2 - San Francisco 49′ers
Their last playoff appearance was in 2002, but the San Francisco 49′ers are just unpredictable enough to be a real pain for analysts. They were moderately popular in 2004 and then won two games. They were slightly more popular in 2005 when they won four games. Their popularity continued to grow in 2006 and 2007 when they won seven and five games respectively. Every year they become a trendier pick, and every year they come up short. I’m even jumping on board this year…I think that the 49′ers could be the NFC #6 seed in 2008. Maybe that’s why the 49′ers are my #2 Trendiest Pre-Season Pick.
#1 - Arizona Cardinals
This should be a no-brainer. The Cardinals have been the trendy pick since I was in high school. Every year they pick up these free agents who are supposed to rejuvenate the team, and every year they finish below .500. Their draft picks have been solid athletes (Larry Fitzgerald, Matt Leinart) but there always seems to be one piece of the puzzle missing (offensive line, defense, running back). Analysts always expect that piece to be discovered during the off-season and make their bold playoff predictions only to see the Cardinals flop. In 2007 they finished .500 for the first time since 1998 and they certainly do appear to be on the verge of something big…
…but that’s why they’re my #1 Trendist Pre-Season Pick.